College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

Police debunk supposed internship hoax

Staff Writer

Published: Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Updated: Wednesday, April 7, 2010 23:04

Students who have been contacted about a shady-sounding internship can rest assured the opportunity is legitimate.

The callers from Southwestern Company arranging information sessions about those internships, to be hosted in Mass Communications building Room 282, represent a Tennessee-based business that does this every year, according to the Texas Tech Police Department. A total of nine reports reached the department involving unwanted electronic communication from the company between March 29 and March 31.

Lynn Huffman, executive associate dean of Academics, Research and Faculty Development for the College of Human Sciences, sent an e-mail to all Human Sciences students urging them to be careful if they received communication regarding summer internships because of the concern she saw in many of her faculty and students.

Capt. Kenny Evans of the Tech Police Department said the electronic communication and subsequent reports from concerned students were part of a “misunderstanding.”

“It was a miscommunication issue all the way around,” Huffman said. “People are nervous about (being stalked or followed) and think the worst.”

Although nine students reported the communication — which included phone calls and text messages — to the police, Evans said the communication came from a legitimate source.

Representatives for Southwestern Company had been contacting students about a summer internship opportunity, Evans said.

Huffman said much of the miscommunication could have been avoided if the Southwestern Company representatives were more clear with students about where they found contact information and why they were calling.

Travis Thompson, a representative for Southwestern Company, said he and his coworkers attain student contact information using two methods: questionnaires and student recommendations.

Those questionnaires are passed out during the first week and a half of each semester and contain a space for students to provide Southwestern Company with their names, majors and telephone numbers, Thompson said.

“I think some of these students had forgotten they had filled out the (questionnaires),” Evans said.

Southwestern Company representatives are allowed to use text messages to remind students about information sessions and interviews to which they have already committed but never use them as a form of their first communication with students, Thompson said.

Nick Dale, also a representative for Southwestern Company, said text message reminders often are necessary.

“They’re college students, and they tend to forget,” he said.

Dale said he could not speculate as to why nine students reported Southwestern Company representatives to the police because he is confident in the company’s methods of communicating with students.

“We give people plenty of chances to say ‘no,’” he said.

Huffman said although she regrets any harm her e-mail may have caused, she does not in any way regret taking measures to keep students safe.

“I regret if anyone has had a problem because of this, but I always want to take care of students,” she said.

After further investigation by the police, Huffman sent a second e-mail to Human Sciences students letting them know all concerns involving the communication had been eased Wednesday.

Huffman said she sent the e-mail at 6:41 p.m. March 30 after being told Mass Communications building Room 282 did not exist.

 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

18 comments

Anonymous
Wed Apr 21 2010 22:41
I worked for the Southwestern Company last summer, and it was honestly one of the best decisions I've ever made in my life. I'm looking forward to working with Southwestern this summer, as well. Students are expected to put time and energy into the program, just like any other internship, and the rewards are GREAT...friendships, travel, financial opportunity, character development...it's an awesome experience. It's too bad that people are so quick to jump to incorrect conclusions.
Anonymous
Sun Apr 18 2010 23:43
I received a phone call from Travis Thompson, and since he did not state what company he was with, I assumed it was a scam. Any professional would mention the company; it's basic telecommunication protocol. The fact he did not mention his company was highly suspicious. Also, I never filled out a survey for this company with my information.
Anonymous
Tue Apr 13 2010 13:08
The company like many companies are not official scams but society is neither just nor right. Students are taught to believe, and they have to believe, that they sell superior educational products that are overpriced. The selling of educational material and using successful college students who go into major Universities to sell this material is an excellent marketing strategy. Preying on the hope of parents and getting kids excited about a product that has no competitive advantage over the internet are the two keys to making this sale and ripping people off. The managers are not up front with you about the system and avoid any questions about how the company works. You spend your first few meetings becoming extended friends. They have a sales speech, a sales program fro selling and recruiting. They are trained. And the good ones are either really greedy or in a financial bind, otherwise they wouldn't be selling a dream. Because the products are overpriced books which they consider educational and supplements to your school, SAT, or getting into college. Don't do it if you have a heart. Also realize this is all about money. They are not likely your friends unless you make the managers money. If you do not make the sells, you will be entirely blamed and your initial investment grows larger the longer you stay in it. You pay for your trip entirely out of your own pocket, from Sales school which you are required to live in a hotel, to materials, to gas money and a car if you have one and any expenses. You don't see a dime of your money that you do make until the end of the summer. Meaning if you need money to continue working then you are screwed. You go door to door asking people to let you live with them in a new state. Since people aren't familiar with out of state universities, it's easy to make sales and use the prestige of the university to sell dreams and not valuable productive products. You will be harassed by police, and all the elements as a door to door salesmen in a different state. People don't like to be conned or bothered repeatedly. No means NO, also YES they DO hate the Product, but they also Hate door to door salesmen.
Anonymous
Sun Apr 11 2010 17:47
For the real truth about the Direct Sales Industry and door-to-door sales please review our websites:
www.travelingsalescrews.info
www.dedicatedmemorial.org

Sincerely,
DMPG webmaster

Conrad Alagaban, Jr.
Sat Apr 10 2010 11:45
I want to clarify that it costs the company at least $2000 to train and prepare each student selected for the internship.
Conrad Alagaban, Jr.
Sat Apr 10 2010 11:42
People do not have the same perspectives so what may seem a benefit to some maybe a detriment to others. I love this country because we are free to choose who we work for or with. As with ALL companies, there are positive and negative perspectives from both clients and employers. The Southwestern Company has one of the oldest and most challenging summer program for college students. The internship offers the chance for students to build on "soft"/ transferable skills by selling educational supplements to families after going through a rigorous selection and training process at the cost of a couple thousand dollars per student selected. Students live with host families in a different state and live off the money they earn. That is not easy. Some will do well, some will not. All will gain invaluable life lessons about what it takes to be successful in managing oneself. Some customers will be pleased with the products. Some will not. And if a company has been around for more than a hundred years and still turns a profit, more often than not it is providing a valuable service for customers and a positive experience for employees and business partners.
Melanie
Fri Apr 9 2010 10:06
I'm glad to see alll the SW book-kids being so supportive of TX Tech and Travis and Nick. Keep up the good work and I'm glad this didn't get out of hand.
Manny in DE
Fri Apr 9 2010 09:13
I am reading about this story in Wilmington, DE which shows the network of SW alum. I sold summers 1987-89 and have hosted students from AZ in 2006 and UT in 2009. The money you EARN will eventually be spent but the lessons you LEARN will last a lifetime. It is a fantastic opportunity for mature, young adults.
Cole C.
Thu Apr 8 2010 14:43
I worked with Southwestern for 3 years in college, and because of it I graduated debt-free. The only people who claim this is a scam are the ones that don't work hard and therefore, don't earn much. Working with Southwestern was the best decision I ever made, and Travis, Nick, and everybody else recruiting at Tech are awesome. I haven't sold since 2007 and I just received yet another check from The Southwestern Company for work I put in during college!
Anonymous
Wed Apr 7 2010 23:59
I worked with Southwestern for 6 years and developed the programs at TTU and TX State. The impact this experience has on students, their families, and the future is not measured by the dollar but whom they become in the process. This experience teaches principles of success, work ethic, and habits every student can share in their future interviews. The real life sales experience will give them the confidence to get the job they want because they have the experience to back up the resume. As I and many alumni would agree that when comes to the interview process, the Southwestern experience, is the highlight of the interview because I did something majority of America couldn't fathom doing. You can be successful in Southwestern as long as you are committed to doing well. Everything has a price, you just have to be willing to "pay the price."
Manny Gonzalez, Texas State
Wed Apr 7 2010 23:11
I personally got recruited for this job six years ago through filling out a questionaire in one of my class. I forgot that I had filled one out until my recruiter told me that's how he got my info. I am glad that I did fill it out because it was the best decision that I ever made in college. If you get offered a spot on the Tech Team take it because it will be the best experience for you!
Amy L
Wed Apr 7 2010 18:03
I have done this internship for the last four summers and have never worked any other hourly wage job since. Not only did I profit immensely, but gained over 9 hours of college credit and met my best friends. It is an incredible experience and I would encourage every hard-working student to look into it. Travis and Nick could help you graduate debt free and set you up for the real world big time. As with anything in life, you get back what you put into it. www.southwestern.com.
nate foss Tx state
Wed Apr 7 2010 15:07
I go to Texas State and have done this internship every summer I've been in College. This program is the bomb.com and has funded 100% of my college expenses.
Anonymous
Wed Apr 7 2010 14:48
The last anonymous comment was made by me.
Anonymous
Wed Apr 7 2010 14:46
Lynn Huffman needs to check her sources before sending out mass emails. The representatives from Southwestern at Texas Tech University are not only credible, but they are making a positive difference in these students' lives. Dr. Huffman is hindering the successful development of her students when engaging in impulsive actions for "safety measures". Although her intentions were good, she made a huge mistake. A handful of professional academics always think they're right--when truly as circumstances as these show they are far from it.
Randi Rivers, Rawls College of Business, TTU
Wed Apr 7 2010 12:39
It would be wise for any student who has been personally called, or personally contacted in anyway, to ensure that any company offering an interview opportunity, or internship, is indeed a legitimate company, and that the interview and/or internship does indeed exist, and that the interview location exists as well. Being safe after the fact just isn't a good idea.
Kudos to Lynn Huffman for being concerned enough to issue a warning to our students regarding a possible scam.
Amy
Wed Apr 7 2010 12:10
Perhaps rather than speculating about "knowing people who have done some research" you should do your own, or even attend an info session. During my time at Tech, I worked a summer with Southwestern and recruited for them as well. It was a valuable experience and the company is completely legitimate.
Anonymous
Wed Apr 7 2010 01:15
The company and internship may be real but that doesn't mean it's a beneficial opportunity. I know people who have done some research into it and found that it's not what it seems or promises. Tech should be advised to investigate and then decide if it's really a company with which they want to maintain any sort of affiliation or recommend to students.






log out